Welcome to Lefty's Gourmet Pizza and Ice Cream
Lefty's Gourmet Pizza and Ice Cream, located in Niwot, CO, offers a delightful dining experience that combines the best of both worlds: gourmet pizza and sweet, creamy ice cream. Known for its warm atmosphere and attentive staff, Lefty's has garnered a loyal following, with customers praising its fresh ingredients and generous portions. From delectable calzones enjoyed on the patio to pizza that sets the standard for quality, each dish is crafted with care. The new management has created a sense of community, making guests feel like family. A visit to Lefty’s is not just a meal; it's an experience worth savoring.
Lefty's Gourmet Pizza and Ice Cream: Reviews & Ratings
This was a super cute place with very attentive counter help. The kids seemed to really like the flavors they chose.
I love Lefty’s/Niwot Pizza so much. I have been coming here since I was quite literally born. This is what my standard for good pizza is based off of. On top of all of that, since coming under new management, this place has treated me like family. Lorenzo, if you see this, keep doing what you’re doing because you’re doing a great job. Both myself and the rest of the community appreciate what you do so much. -Alex
Great that this place was right next to The Niwot Inn... Cuz my boyfriend was able to down , get the pie and get it back to the room while it was still hot and used my stomach as a place ! Lol
This place was an absolute delight. Stopped in for lunch and ate a calzone on the patio. The ingredients were super fresh and everything delicious. The small calzone was plenty big. The atmosphere is very pleasant and the owners personable and nice. 10/10 will stop by again.
We stopped in on a weekday for lunch. Ordered calzones and so glad we did. They were amazing! We will definitely be back. Service was great!
I recently had the pleasure of trying out this fantastic pizza shop and I have to say, it exceeded all of my expectations! The pizza was simply amazing - fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. I especially loved the crispy crust and the generous toppings - it was clear that the ingredients were of the highest quality. In addition to the outstanding pizza, the customer service was top-notch. The staff were friendly, welcoming, and eager to make sure I had a great experience. They even gave me some recommendations on their favorite menu items and helped me customize my order to my liking.
My boyfriend and I went for lunch on a week day and got two slices of pizza and rocky road ice cream. The slices are huge for a great price. They taste amazing and I told my boyfriend it was like eating spaghetti as a pizza. It was amazing. Nice and quiet atmosphere with very friendly workers.
Delicious pizza! Ingredients were amazing. Pepperoni was excellent. Smell in the store was divine. This shop is a hidden gem in the nice town of Niwot. It’s not far out of boulder and is worth the drive if there is going to be a wait elsewhere. Pizza is more expensive but a small can feed 2 if you’re not too hungry
Location
-
364 2nd Ave, Niwot, CO 80503, United States Hotline: +1 303-652-3100
Welcome to Lefty's Gourmet Pizza and Ice Cream, a beloved culinary gem nestled at 364 2nd Ave in picturesque Niwot, Colorado. This charming establishment is not just a place to satisfy your hunger—it's a community spot where flavors and family come together in delightful harmony.
From the moment you step through the doors, you're greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels just like home. Customers rave about the attentive service, with many expressing their appreciation for the friendly staff that goes above and beyond to ensure a satisfying dining experience. As Doris Mati noted, the "super cute place" is perfect for families, offering flavors that bring smiles to children's faces—truly a place where happy memories are made.
For pizza purists and flavor adventurers alike, Lefty's has become a benchmark of what good pizza should taste like. Soul Tuna TV, a longtime customer, captures the essence of this establishment perfectly, mentioning that "this is what my standard for good pizza is based off of." Under new management, the restaurant has cultivated a familial vibe, making it a cherished staple in the community. Lorenzo, along with his team, has not just maintained but enhanced the quality and passion that Lefty’s is known for.
Those on the hunt for more than just pizza will be delighted with the offerings at Lefty's. Calzones and various specialty dishes shine with their fresh ingredients and generous portions. Corey Langseth shares how he enjoyed a lunch on the patio, describing the ingredients as "super fresh" and the entire experience as an "absolute delight." The small calzone was, as he put it, "plenty big," satisfying and filling enough to make any lunchtime visit memorable.
Whether you're dropping in for a casual weekday lunch or picking up a delicious pie for a cozy night in, Lefty's Gourmet Pizza and Ice Cream promises quality, flavor, and a touch of community spirit. J. Squires perfectly captures this atmosphere with a humorous nod to pizza and love, delivering it hot and fresh, ready to be enjoyed.
In essence, Lefty's is not just about feeding hunger; it's about nurturing relationships, caring for its customers, and creating a space where everyone feels like family. With consistently great service and dishes that delight both young and old, Lefty's Gourmet Pizza and Ice Cream stands out as a must-visit dining destination in Niwot. So bring your appetite, leave your worries at the door, and prepare to be wowed by the delicious offerings at Lefty’s!